You are here

But You Don't Really Think Of Her As Your Stepdaughter, Do You?

TwoOfUs's picture

So. Quick story that perfectly encapsulates step-life.

I took my niece and her friend out for her birthday yesterday. We ended up going about 40 minutes away, to this tiny mountain town. Went on a hike, panned for gems, got some ice cream at a little candy shop & ice cream parlor.

Lots of nice old people around commenting on how cute my niece and her friend are, talking to them, enjoying having some little kids around. I'm talking to some of the people while the kids eat their ice cream and I say something about "my stepdaughter" as part of a story. Immediately, this really nice older man leans over to me and says:

Old Man: "I don't think the world should have any stepdaughters, do you?"

Me: "Ummm...excuse me?"

Old Man: "Don't you just think of her as your own? She's your daughter, right? And don't you just hate saying that word? Sounds like someone's getting stepped on!!"

Me: "Ha! Ummm...well. I mean. I guess the word can have some...negative...connotations at times...and, I do get along with my stepdaughter...I have a kind of...love for her...but..."

Old Man: "I know you do! I can tell by how you talk about her. I think you should just call her your daughter because that's how you feel! No need for all this step-this and half-that nonsense! You know what I mean?"

Me: "Yeah...ummm. Well, she has a mom, though...I do get what you're saying, but I don't know that blurring the line...I don't know that acting like her mom or calling her my daughter is the answer..."

Anyway. I don't remember how the conversation wrapped up. Just that 1.) It was incredibly awkward, and 2.) As soon as I said the word "stepdaughter" some stranger felt completely justified to butt in and give his opinion on my family dynamic...free to lecture me on how I should feel and react toward my "stepdaughter" without knowing anything about me, about her, or about our relationship and history together. And that, in a nutshell, is how most of the world reacts to you when you're a stepmom...free to butt in, advise, lecture, criticize...tell you how to feel about it.

After the older man left, the woman who owned the shop rang me up and said: "I have a stepdaughter, too. Trust me...I know that you're the one getting 'stepped on' in that situation." Hehehe. I laughed and we commiserated for a while. I admitted that there was a time when I wouldn't have minded "stepping on" my oldest SD so much. So it's not all bad...

Comments

TwoOfUs's picture

lol. I love it! If this man hadn't been so nice the whole time we were there I might have done something similar. Honestly, I think he's just incredibly naive...which is true of anyone who hasn't lived it, I guess. I was curt with him when he wouldn't drop it, but mainly I just let it go and reminded myself to mention it on here...

CANYOUHELP's picture

Every situation is different, but the more I read here, the more in common we all have....it is great to get the advise, both good and bad.

Clearly, blended families must not be easy for most people. It is great this site because it allows you to connect with people who have similar situations; as often we feel guilty and alone, and like you, we sometimes feel a need to change or improve our own behavior. When, in fact, there is little or nothing you can do to change the situation. We never created it and we may not be the answer, or the problem, at all.

You are the ultimate judge of your situation. And, nobody has experienced it but you. Advise is always helpful, even from those we do not know, but you have to take it for what it is and decide if there is any take away for YOU.

notasm3's picture

I do not claim my husband's son on any level. I refer to him here as SS30 for convenience's sake.

He's a worthless POS that I DO NOT WANT IN MY LIFE. He had a baby with his GF last December. I do not wish the child ill at all, but I want nothing to do with him either. He will most likely turn out just like his father. (violent drunk who abuses women and the elderly)

I have no problem telling anyone that he is not part of my life. He is NOT my stepson. He's just a POS that my DH produced by having a ONS with his ex years after their divorce. All of that was decades before I met DH - just not relevant to my life.

As far as I am concerned my husband's son is the equivalent of his taking a crap. Just shit.

Last In Line's picture

Obviously the old geezer was without a proper reference point.

I probably would have said "Her mom doesn't like it when I call her child mine" and gone on about my business.

TwoOfUs's picture

Lol.

YSD is very tall...so in a way I do use her to reach the high shelves from time to time...

notasm3's picture

Dup

The4Nuggets's picture

I do not at all think of my SD as my own. Sometimes when meeting a new person or having a conversation with a stranger, I say "daughter" as to not go into details. But everyone that knows me knows she's my step daughter. I always make that very clear. Her and I are nothing alike. We have nothing in common. It's actually kinda hard to bond with her when she's here. I usually just have to fake it until it's over. I don't feel that she's even here enough for me to love her like that. Sometimes it feels like a stranger is in my home for the weekend.

step.life's picture

Yeah people dont have a clue. Sure when SD starts calling me "mom" then I'll drop the 'step' part of Stepdaughter. Like the BMs ever allow skids to call us any version of mom. My BM spanked that idea out of my SD when she was a 3yo. Before she used to call me "mommy step.life". Not to mention Skids will always make sure to insert themselves into the adult conversation to say "she's not my mom, she's my STEPmom!" (probably from fear of being reprimanded by their BM) There's no reason for us to not say the truthful term.

TwoOfUs's picture

Exactly!!

As I've tried to tell my DH many times: "You would never, ever ask your kids to love me 'just like they love their mom' because that would be unkind, cruel...we instantly recognize that that would be an impossible request. But, for some reason, we think stepmoms are 'deficient' or 'evil' if they can't love the kids 'like their own.'"

Such a double standard.

thinkthrice's picture

Sounds like the old man was/still is a guilty/disney biodad; maintaining his ever vigilant world view of the "one big , happy family model" (TM) sprinkled with unicorns farting glitter and rainbows. Typical.

hereiam's picture

But You Don't Really Think Of Her As Your Stepdaughter, Do You?

No, not at all, I think of her as my husband's daughter.

TwoOfUs's picture

Amen! I would love it if it were all happy first marriages, no death, no divorce...no bad decisions or selfish actions...and so no stepchildren and no step parents. I think we could all get on board with that Smile

But to not live in that perfect world and to assume the SM can fix it with love and self-sacrifice...is naive at best, cruel and unusual punishment at worst...

ESMOD's picture

Even though I care about both of my stepdaughters and am proud to see them both grow into hardworking young women, I am still not their biological mother. I believe it's a matter of respect to the bio parents to not try to usurp that role. I suppose it might be a little different for a stepparent who was the "only" father/mother the child had ever known and the bio parent was dead (or the equivalent). I actually don't even like the BM of my girls and certainly really don't respect her as a person, but I do respect her role in my stepdaughter's life.

I have had multiple people comment on how good a relationship I have with them. I don't go way out of my way to correct a stranger if they say I have a lovely daughter because I honestly don't want to have to explain it all, but when I refer to them, I do refer to them as stepdaughters. They call me by my name.

It's a little complicated but, we all make our own way ya know?

TwoOfUs's picture

I'm in the same boat. I have a good relationship with skids, I don't go out of my way to correct people who assume they're mine...but I still don't feel that bio connection or expect them to feel it toward me. I still struggle with resentment from time-to-time.

TwoOfUs's picture

I'm in the same boat. I have a good relationship with skids, I don't go out of my way to correct people who assume they're mine...but I still don't feel that bio connection or expect them to feel it toward me. I still struggle with resentment from time-to-time.

kathc's picture

I hate when people feel the need to make comments like that. I've been told many times how I "should be happy I have skid". Um, why? Why should i be happy to be forced to have someone under my roof who gives me dirty looks? Why should i be happy to pay for things for someone else's child? Happy my ass!

kathc's picture

YES!!!

I'm supposed to act like this is the child I"ve always longed for... I've started just saying to people, "If I wanted kids, I'd have my own and MINE would be GOOD kids!"

TwoOfUs's picture

Lol. I'm the OP and I'm childless as well. Thankfully no one in my life has been callous enough to suggest these skids are a good replacement for kids of my own. I do get along with all of them quite well...but they have a mom! They care for me, but they certainly don't love me or treat me like a mom...

ESMOD's picture

Or, yeah, I have all the responsibility of helping to raise these kids but when the chips are down, they will still not be my children. So, I get the inconvenience and the headaches of dealing with them, but when I am old and gray, they won't be coming to visit me in the nursing home.

And I feel this way and i actually care about my step kids! But, I am under no illusion that they will have loyalty to the BM over me.

TwoOfUs's picture

I'm in the same boat. Love and care for my skids, get along fine. I often do and buy things for them...by choice. And I always have, but I've always been generous with my money.

Recently, YSD16, who I've always been the closest to, went on a trip to NYC with her dad. The trip was my idea...and I paid for most of it. She came home earlier than my DH (he stayed longer for business), and I'm the one who drove an hour and a half to pick her up at the airport. We had a great talk about everything she did and saw...how much she loved it. I was happy for her, of course. Then she talks about souvenirs that she bought...for her mom, her sister, and her brother. The intact first family...not for me or DH, the ones who actually made the trip possible. While she was telling me about these things, I could tell it occurred to her that she left me out, and she said that I could "have this bath bomb" that she got at LUSH...clearly an afterthought...and, unfortunately, I don't have a tub.

Now, honestly, I don't care about this. I don't need a teen to spend her hard-earned spending money on some trinket for me. But it was eye-opening and revealing. In the moment...I am not considered. And, yeah, I'm not expecting nursing home visits, either. So...everything I give I give knowing that it will never be returned in any way. This is why I've had to put limits on my generosity...both in terms of my time and financial resources and my heart / attention...not because I've quit being generous but because I have to save some for myself and protect myself.