You are here

I could really use some advice to see if I'm being a jerk in this situation...

CountryStepmom36's picture

Hi everyone.  I'll try to keep this as short as possible, because this situation spans over three years.  My husband and I have been married for seven years.  He has a teenaged stepson.  My husband and his ex-wife split up 13 years ago.  She is on Husband Number 3.  So my stepson began having a lot of behavioral problems several years ago, and eventually he was diagnosed with ODD and ADHD.  For some weird reason, my husband was reluctant to put him in therapy (!), but that's another story. 

My stepson was sent to live with his maternal grandparents.  This made no sense to me, because he was living with his mother (the primary parent) and stepfather (Husband Number 2.)  My stepson could have also come to live with us, but that didn't happen.  Instead, he was sent to live with his elderly grandparents.  They do EVERYTHING for him!  My stepson is home-schooled, and his grandmother facilitates the home-schooling.  My husband still pays child support to his ex-wife despite the fact that this kid doesn't live with her!  The grandparents recently paid a lot of money to enroll my stepson into a driving school, and my husband didn't pay a dime.  I pitched a fit!  Eventually, through my ranting, my husband gave them some money. 

Herein lies my problem.  When I married my husband, one of the things that attracted me to him was that he seemed to be a very devoted parent.  Now, I just see my husband as a lazy man who pushes off his parenting responsibilities to his ex-inlaws.  He always pays his child support, and he picks up his son during his weekends, which is great.  My issue is that my husband should be paying this child support to the grandparents.  When I confront my husband about this, he gets upset with me and tells me to back off.  He told me that he still pays his ex, because he doesn't want his son to live with her.  That doen't make any sense to me.  I have even asked my husband to show proof that his ex-wife is actually giving the child support money to her parents, and my husband has never asked her about this.  Over the years, I have grown more and more resentful of the situation.  I have also lost so much respect for my husband.  Does anyone have any advice for me?  Am I the one that's being the jerk, or am I married to a jerk?    (Sorry for the long post.)

Comments

ESMOD's picture

When my YSD was in 2nd grade.. she wanted to live with us.  My DH agreed to continue to pay CS to their mom.. 

When both the girls were in HS (at different times).. they both finished up living with their grandparents (my DH's parents).  This was for a variety of reasons.. first schools better.. 2nd.. fighting with mom (NCP).. third.. we lived in a fairly remote area ourselves.. and DH traveled for work.. so wasn't conducive to parenting full time.  Again.. he still paid BM.. and she would not agree at that time for them to live with us... so the next best thing to get them away from their mother's toxic home.. was to allow them to live with his grandparents.

In your case.. Legally, he is meeting his responsibility by paying CS to his EX.  It would have been better, I guess, to have his son live with him.. but for various reasons.. maybe that wasn't going to be in the cards.. (and in the end.. you probably are lucky).

Should he pay the grandparents?  well.. technically, he is paying his ex.. so if SHE is giving HER primary parenting responsibility to her parents.. SHE should be compensating... so I get him not paying double.

BUT.. for the driving school?  I think your DH should pitch in for these kinds of extra expenses.. directly to her parents.

 

CLove's picture

So, for whatever reason things have slid down this slippery slope and youve lost the respect. 

If you do not have separate finances, I would consider separating them now. 

You can ask questions and be there as a support partner, but you cannot push him to "do the right thing" especially since you are getting pushback. Thats his deal, and you have to be ok with it. He probably doesnt want to upset the apple cart and if BMS aged parents are willing to do this and BM is not giving them the money, thats on HER. Hes paying his share, and thats all he can do. It would be an expensive endeavor to go through courts to manage this, as many on here have seen. So, just do the countdown like we all do. Then it wont be an issue. 

Driving class he definitely should help pay for. 

Catmom024's picture

He has to give the child support money to whomever it was legally agreed to.  He doesn't want to go to court to have it changed?  Is he thinking if he gives the child support to the grandparents,  his ex will take back the skid to live with her just to get the $$ again? And he doesn't want that to happen?

I know there was a year when my S.O. had custody of his youngest son 24/7.  It was supposed to be 50/50 but the BM and step father kicked the kid out.  He wouldn't go back to court and just kept paying for a year until the kid turned 18.  He figured she'd want to switch back to 50/50 to avoid her paying child support ($ only flowed in one direction  in this situation and it was always to BM) and he'd just sold his business so his income looked really high.  He wanted to leave well enough alone.  Funny how that always works to the benefit of BM.  Seems they have these men trained to just hand over the $$.

ESMOD's picture

Sometimes we have to get to the bottom of what do we want.. what will in totallity make our lives and everyone's lives better.

In the grand scheme of things.. if the kid is better out of BM's home.. and having him in his dad's home isn't a good solution.. because BM would likely fight it.. because  CS.. it may just be better to let this sleeping dog lie.. pay her the money she is due per the CO.. hope that she is giving her parents some of that money.. and exercise his visitation when available to him.  I would also say that he should try to pay for EXTRAS like the driving lessons.. unless the lessons were something he does not agree with..doesn't want his son driving for example.

Rags's picture

Your DH does not owe his XILs CS. He owes his failed family breeding partner CS wich in all liklihood is clearly defined in the CO.

To stop paying the XW(CP) and start paying the XILs will likely put him in violation of the CS portion of the CO.

And... he should pay not one Cent more than what is COd as CS or other contributions (Usually half of medical bills not covered by insurance, etc....).  Not a single Cent.

CS covers DH's entire obligation for the support of his child and pays his X for caring for the kid when the kid is not with DH.  If XW outsources the care of that kid to her parents.... so be it.  As the CP, that is her choice and her choice alone.  Unfortunately the CP cannot be held accountable for how they spend CS paid by the NCP. DH's CS covers everything he owes, including driving lessons for his child. What BM spends it on, is up to her.  DH has zero obligation to pay his XILs.

We spent some money gaining this lesson when we attempted to collect for half of sports equipment costs, half of band instrument costs, etc... Nope. The Judge gave us clarity.  The CS is the NCP's entire obligation for the support of the Skid unless otherwise stipulated in the CO. In our case, in addition to CS, the NCP was required to pay 50% of any medical related expenses not covered by medical insurance, and 50% of long distance visitation travel costs. Each party was required to pay for the transport of the kid to their location for travel too and from SpermLand for visitation.

"Herein lies my problem"  You have the "(your) problem" part absolutely right. This is your problem and you are also making it a problem for your DH and for your marriage. When it is not a legitimate problem. Enjoy your relatively drama free blended family marriage. Do not stir up shit that does not have to be stired up.

So, stay out of it, learn the CO in totality, and ...... stop injecting drama into a situation that appears to be at a tolerable status quo.

I get that the BM is a POS.  But since her abdication as a parent in favor of her own parents keeps her out of your Cheerios, stop being a PITA for your DH.  Set and enforce standards of behavior and standards of performance for SS when he is in your home. You cannot rescue him from the shallow and polluted end of his gene pool though it is tragic that he is primarily being raised by the same people who created the POS BM.

IMHO of course.

Take care of you.

Give rose

CountryStepmom36's picture

Thank you everyone for your comments.  You all gave me a lot of clarity to this situation.  <3