You are here

What is the right thing to do?

Caitlin's picture

I have a dilemma. SD11 has many school events and my fiance and I would like to attend. The trouble is, BM has "banned" me from the school after I attended open house at the beginning of the year. No, she doesn't have a legal leg to stand on, but she states that I am not a legal member of SD's family and not a resident of the school district and I therefore have no legal right to be there. She sent a letter to the principal, the superintendant, the president of the school board and a thousand other people saying that I have misrepresented myself as the SM, because she and my fiance are still married and she, as the BM, does not want me there. She did not mention anywhere that she filed for divorce almost 4 years ago, but refuses to close it since I've come into the picture because she loves preventing us from being able to marry; she did not mention that they have not lived as a family unit for several years now and that my fiance and I are partners and spouses in every sense minus the marriage certificate, but I digress.

Back to the dilemma. If my fiance is to attend SD's school events on his own, it creates great hardship. He doesn't drive, and must take 3 different buses to get to the school. Today, for example, the school had a Thanksgiving lunch and he couldn't go because he would have had to take the entire day off work for a half hour affair, whereas if we had driven together, we could've done it. BM wrote him an email today, saying how hurt and dissappointed she and SD were that he wasn't there and that she hoped in the future he would make an effort to come. ALONE. (ie: without me.) She knows that it is darn near impossible for him to get there on his own and refuses to drive him herself - not that we'd want to rely on her for anything though!

Now, I am not trying to step on BM's toes. I am trying to support my partner and SD. Maybe it's not my place to attend SD's school events. That's why I want feedback from you. Am I wrong to want to show love and support for his child at her school? This should not be about BM, it should be about SD and her relationship with her daddy that I am here to help facilitate.

I already attend SD's sporting events and music recitals - I'm the one who gets her there on our time together - so I think that BM's lawyer told her the only place she had any control over my presence is at the school, so that is where this is coming from. How can we put a stop to her controlling how our family operates? It is not her decision! I would love love LOVE to get a lawyer and put an end to all this, but unfortunately it is out of the question. We are in a financial nightmare right now so we are unfortunately stuck under her thumb indefinitely because she'll never close the divorce because of the power it affords her.

For right now, our choices are: fiance and I attend school events together, or not at all. If we go, BM throws a fit saying "that woman has no right to be here, I'M THE MOTHER" and SD suffers. If we don't go, BM throws a fit saying "daddy doesn't care enough about you to come" and SD suffers. Advice? What is the right thing to do?

Comments

happy's picture

The issue is she is jealous that he has moved on with his life with someone else.. 4 years in my opinion is too long for a divorce. Whether she likes you or not you are there and she is not. Its also that she wants to hold all the power. In which case she is because you have stepped back and do not go to functions. How can a school if you are obeying the rules if they have told you that you may not attend any functions that is not right.. How can this woman write a letter and complain to any of them. I mean my heavens.. How old is she 10?
I would say that your MAN... Needs to state it to her like this or in some form of this.
***I will be unable to attend these functions due to the fact that I do not drive and my only way to get there is my partner. At this time until you decide to be an adult and learn to deal with the consequences of your actions.. (Remember you filed for divorce).. I will not be able to attend. I would then sit daughter down and discuss it with her age appropriately.
I cannot believe this woman is behaving this way. How rude.. And to be honest no matter what she tries to pull, there daughter will still love her dad and you no matter what her mom tries to pull.

I do have to be nosey and ask how come he does not drive? If I may..

Nise's picture

I think I would go and let her make a fool of herself and make the mom responsilbe for dealing with the consequences of her actions….is it better for her to be upset with her dad for not coming or upset with her mom for acting a fool and ruining the event? If she “shows out” when she finds out that you are there and SD asks daddy not to bring you, then I would take that as the opportunity to explain to SD that the only way daddy can make it is if Caitlin brings him (i.e. you know daddy cannot drive b/c of XYZ right, and that is why Caitlin takes you to your practices….well that is why Caitlin came to your school event, 1. b/c she thinks you are the neatest kid on the planet and she just loves to see you (perform, get an award, etc) and 2. she has to drive daddy so he can come cheer you on as well)

Then the ball is in psychomom’s court when she has to explain to her daughter why she would rather cause a scene then cheer her daughter on

Make a GREAT Day!

Caitlin's picture

He made the decision not to drive so as to not contribute to the world's dependency on oil, so it's a combination political/moral/ethical thing. (Funny, he has no trouble with RIDING in a car, though! LOL) He has always lived in the city and never needed a car, but now that we have moved for my job, we're in the suburbs and it's not quite so easy anymore. He is saying that he's willing to get his license now that we've moved, but with things being so busy and hectic, he hasn't carved out the time to do it. Plus, we do NOT have the money to be a two-car family right now anyway. But he could always drive my car to SD's events, of course.

Anyway, thanks for the advice. I will share it with my MAN so he can step up to the plate! A little background: during their 5 year marriage (and ever since obvously) BM was extremely controlling and manipulative and my fiance fueled the beast by doing everything to make her happy, ie. complying to her every demand. He thought that was best for SD, keeping mommy "happy". Since I've been in the picture, he's finally started standing up for himself, which she is none to pleased about of course. Anyway, when she pulls this type of thing, we need to remind ourselves not to let her have all the control. However, I am TRYING TO BE UNDERSTANDING TO HER AS THE BIOMOM. If it is not my place to go her kid's school, then I want to hear it from those who know.

hopeful's picture

Caitlin, it sounds as though everyone has control in this situation but you. If you are involved enough to drive dad around, bring him to events, supply the car, etc., then you should be able to go to these events with him if you want to. You are a part of the family in every other way. Take care.

Caitlin's picture

The trouble with BM acting like a fool is that poor SD doesn't get (or hasn't yet gotten) mad at HER for it, but mad at US for causing it. She is so protective of her bipolar mommy. Anyway, we will do our best to explain to SD without badmouthing BM in the process.

happy's picture

Its time to put that " manipulative witch " in her happy place.. LOL.. Its time for her to step off her thrown cuz theres a new queen in town ( Caitlyn )... I agree to talk to the daughter and let her know that you love her and care for her and will be there for her when she needs..
In all seriousness the bm can always and will always be her mom no matter what happens.. We who all have bio kids know that we will always be the mom.. That is a fact.. But I think that she needs to stop acting like a child..
Start going to those functions.. Show you have class.. When she starts acting like a child just ignore her.. She will be the one walking out of that place with "Ima Dumb Ass" written across her forehead..

You have in my eyes all rights to be a part of her life.. Her daddy has chosen you..

Smile and have a great weekend..

gazoogleheimer's picture

My DH was in a similar situation. BM made it clear that she didn't want *him* at any school functions. She would tell him not to go. She would tell the school that he wasn't supposed to be there. She went so far as to keep SD out of school on the days when DH was volunteering in the classroom.

Sigh...

DH pushed back sometimes, simply went about exercising his rights. BM was never at any of SD's school functions, anyway - just got mad after the fact when she found out he was there (or beforehand if she knew he was planning to attend). The sad part was that it had to be so hard for SD to have to live with that, listening to her mom going off about these things, grilling her to find out if her dad had been at the school, keeping her out of school, home from events, discouraging her from joining extracurricular activities.

So, sometimes DH would give in, too. Sad Leaving SD with no one there at all, but peace in her life.

Even now, when she's living with us, she thinks it so weird how involved DH & I are involved in DS's school & activities.

You and everyone are very, very, very correct that you have every right to be there. And, SD has every right to have you there. She also has a right to peace in her life, but has a volatile controlling BM to deal with. That's got to be so hard for her. And, I'm sure that it's just as hard for you & your DH to make the decisions about attending these things & find the right balance given the reality of the situation.

I don't really know what's right for your family. I don't think anyone ever knows for sure in these kinds of situations. Just keep on trying your best to salvage a normal, happy, enriching childhood for your husband's daughter.

monica68's picture

YOU SAID IT! Trust yourself, you sound 'right on'.
Being a 'Step Mom' and a 'Bio Mom', I feel so sad when I read comments like this. It's ABSURD! She sounds like the same sort of 'control freak' (I'm putting it VERY nicely) that my husband's ex is; our situations sound identical.
Go with your fiance to the events, ignore her as much as possible, and continue to love your step daughter.
You're awesome!
And remember: 'The best revenge is success' AND: 'What goes around comes around' (or vice-versa, whatever! KARMA)
(It's the truth, I speak from experience!)
Aloha, MJ

monica68's picture

CHECK OUT LEGAL AID...get the divorce finalized!
...and live happily ever after (LOL)
Aloha, MJ

Anne 8102's picture

He's the father, he has the right to go. You are living in a committed relationship, you have the right to go if he wants you there, if the child wants you there and if you want to be there. She can either (1) get a grip on reality or (2) make an ass of herself. Number one would be the ideal, but number two could be fun to watch! No sane person would deny the child the love and support of a parent, whether that parent is biological, adopted or step.

Think of all the gay couples with adopted children who don't have "legal" marriages. If they can do it, so can you. Did anyone read about the lesbian couple who had a child via artificial insemination and the courts granted them equal rights as parents? Even though there were two "mothers" and only one of them was a biological parent to the child, the courts gave the non-bio mother equal standing as a parent in the family, just as both moms and dads have equal standing in traditional families. Now, why is this important? Because it sets a precedence for all stepfamilies or blended families, whatever you want to call them. In stepfamilies, the same is true... you have a mother, in our case we would be stepmothers, who are not biologically related to the child, but living in a committed relationship and/or marriage to the child's biological parent. It's an important ruling, because it will eventually give stepparents equal rights as co-parents without having to go through an adoption process.

But back to your situation. I agree that you guys need to get to a lawyer pronto and get this divorce finalized. You keep saying that she won't sign. Well, that's fine. Use legal aid if you need to, but get a lawyer to petition the court for a judgement against her for the divorce. You can get a divorce even if the other person doesn't want to. You just show the judge that the separation has lasted several years, there is no hope for reconciliation, that he has moved on and that she is preventing the divorce so as not to allow him the freedom to remarry. The judge can enter a judgement for divorce without her signing a thing and can make a ruling on child support, visitation, etc. at the same time. I would look into that.

Also, make sure that when he does finally get things finalized, that he puts a non-interference clause in the paperwork so that she can only contact him at home for genuine child-related reasons, that she cannot contact you at all, that she cannot call him at work, etc.

~ Anne ~

goldenlife's picture

That's the only way to get your life back. It worked for me. Think of her as a school yard bully. Call her bluff and she will eventually back down.

Been there, done that...saw the stupid look on her face when I walked in and she did...NOTHING!!!!:) Now she's the one that's on the retreat! We are married but it doesn't matter if you never get married. You have a right to be there because you are supporting your mate. Hell, some parents aren't even married, HELLO!

Nymh's picture

I agree with everyone else here. You have every right to be there. If you do decide to go, and BM makes a scene, who will look like the fool? Her. Step families are becoming more and more mainstream lately and pretty much everyone knows someone in your situation if they haven't been in it themselves. People will respect you for being there and showing your support for your SD, and they will have little to no respect for this woman if she does decide to "show out". It will help if you can completely ignore her and keep your attention on SD at all times! They will see you as a classy lady and her as an immature person who needs help.

I also agree that her letter-writing campaign is pretty childish. I mean what is she trying to accomplish? She's basically bad-mouthing you to everyone hoping that they'll join her side and ban you from these activities, thus giving her even more power over you. Well you know what? Unless you are posing a threat to the safety of SD by being there, or there's a restraining or court order against you, I'm pretty sure they can't deny your presence. After all, these are PUBLIC events. If she wants to start up her own "I hate Caitlin" club that only people she approves can attend, that's up to her.

Also: I would strongly suggest pushing to get the divorce finalized. Four years is a ridiculous amount of time to stretch out a divorce, and the only person who is benefiting from it taking this long is her. Perhaps getting that taken care of or at least your BF letting her know that he is not going to sit around forever waiting on her to decide to do it will help her to understand that you two aren't her puppets on strings.

Good luck with everything, keep us updated on how everything goes!

*~So sayeth Nymh~*

Caitlin's picture

I really appreciate everyone's commentary and advice. It's amazing just how manipulative that woman is, because the way she goes on, I start to BELIEVE that she is a victim here! You all have helped me get a major reality check.

I had a great talk with SD over the weekend and we talked very matter-of-factly about her mom. SD brought up the conversation actually, by asking when her dad I were going to get married. It's probably the 10th time she's asked over the last couple of years and we've been telling her things like "as soon as we have all the adult legal stuff sorted out" so as to not badmouth her mother who is, in fact, preventing the divorce from being finalized. But this time, she pushed so I finally said "as soon as your mom allows it." Here's how the conversation went on:

SD (confused): "Oh, well Mommy says that you guys won't provide the papers to finalize the divorce."

Me (a bit shocked, but trying not to show it): "Huh, does that make any sense to you? Your dad and I want to get married so badly. Think about it: your mom has every reason to want us not to get married; we have every reason to want to get married. What do you think the truth is?"

SD: "I don't know, that's just what Mommy told me." (Thoughtful silence...) "You know, Mommy doesn't want you to come to my school and my swim meets and stuff because you and Daddy aren't married and you aren't my family."

Me: "That's right, I didn't know you knew about that. But you know, we are a family now and we'll be a family when your dad and I get married. Nothing will change on our wedding day but a piece of paper. You know, your parents weren't married when you were born, but that doesn't mean that you weren't a family back then, right? I come to your events because I love you, and I love your dad and nothing's going to change that."

SD: "What is Mommy doing to prevent the divorce?"

Me: "Nothing. She's just not making it happen."

SD: "Well, what does she need to do to make it happen?"

Me: "Just as her lawyer to proceed."

SD: "Oh. Well why doesn't Daddy just do it?"

Me: "Well, your mom filed for divorce, so she has the power to close it. Your dad has tried 4 times to close it on his own but they turned him away. Since he's the defendant and we can't afford a lawyer, we just don't know how to make it happen."

SD (like a lightbulb went off in her head): "I think maybe Mommy won't divorce Daddy until he pays the money back." (Referring to the marital debt to BM's father that SHE accrued over their 5-year marriage, but is holding HIM wholly responsible for.)

Me: "Well, your dad already pays 60% of his salary to your mom for child support and alimony and the rest goes to paying back their credit card debt, so there's unfortunately nothing left for that. He can't even contribute to our household as it is."

SD: "I think maybe Mommy thinks you have more money than you do. Not my dad, you. I think Mommy thinks you're rich." (WHAT?!)

Me: "Maybe she does assume that because with a lack of communication like we have, she doesn't have any information to go by, so she just assumes."

SD: "I feel bad for my mom."

Me: "So do I, my love."

Anyway, those are just the highlights. We talked and talked. It felt so good not to have to avoid the truth about her mother's actions and just be open and upfront about the whole situation. SD gets so much poison in her ear from her mom, I think she really wants to hear our side of things to get an idea of what the truth is.

Looking back, I think I may have shared too much information for an 11-year-old to have to bear. Yes, it's too much for her, but I guess she already hears about it from the other side, so she may as well hear the truth. I just feel bad that she's stuck in the middle like this. Can you believe how grown up this little girl is?!

Nise's picture

Congratulations on having an age appropriate conversation with her…in my opinion you did not share too much but others may disagree…it sounds like you were telling her your version of the truth in a loving non-malicious way…I’m sure that her mother has been telling her her version of the truth as well but her version has a lot of malice and anger towards her soon to be ex husband and you attached to it…for her to conclude that she feels sorry for her mom shows that she doesn’t perceive her mom to be happy in life (and I’m sure that comes through when she is telling SD about the “goings on”)…it’s good that she felt comfortable having that conversation with you!

Make a GREAT Day!

sosmomof6's picture

It's great that you and SD had that talk and no, I don't feel it was inappropriate. But if BM has anything to say back to you about it, just brace yourself ahead of time...you know it was to address the problems that BM is making SD aware of, but I have a feeling BM may try to twist it and blame you...try to let it bounce off! I am in a very similar boat, BM has "banned" me from even speaking to or around her because I am not SS's parent. And I'll tell you the same thing I was told, unless you are outright harrassing or slandering or physically abusing or assaulting BM then she can't take any action to prevent you from going to events or being involved. And I completely understand about the bus issue and how long it takes to ride on them back and forth. So as long as SD knows that her Dad isn't missing out intentionally, and when you said she says she feels bad for her mom, it sounds like she realizes that she can't exactly trust her. Which is very sad for SD, but it's great that you and your fiance are there to foster a healthy and loving relationship.

P.S. Our oldest daughter is named Caitlin Smile

Caitlin's picture

Even when things are relatively quiet, I am aware that BM is likely to be cooking something up and could strike at any time.

And yes, you are absolutely right, she will find a way to blame me. She is always doing this because all of her problems are always someone else's fault. I just don't engage with her. My fiance and I just repeat the mantra "I'm sorry you feel that way." All she wants to do is fight and if we just keep repeating that, it's impossible to even have a fight, which infuriates her of course!

The most important thing is being there for SD and just ignoring the fallout from BM. As a matter of fact, SD has a band/choir concert on Wednesday and we'll be there to support her, smiling and waving from the audience. BM will be furious that I dare show up at HER kid's concert. It'll probably go something like this:

BM (seething): 'Dave', your GIRLFRIEND has no right to be here.
[Added note: she likes to call me the "girlfriend" to minimize my role as partner, spouse, stepmother, mother, one of the heads of household, an important member of the family. She spits that word out with added emphasis to make sure everyone hears we're not married.]

Us (smiling and remaining upbeat for SD): I'm sorry you feel that way.

BM (dripping venom): She is not SD's family member, nor a resident of this school district, I can have her removed!

Us (smiling and waving at SD): We're sorry you feel that way.

BM (hissing at this point): You are not listening to what I'm saying!!

Us (hearing perfectly well): We're sorry you feel that way. We're going to sit and watch the performance now.

P.S. Caitlin's a great name! (And the perfect spelling!)