You are here

Is this unreasonable asking?

Daisygirl99's picture

Summary is my husband goes to visit his 28 year old daughter and his grandchild once a month without me because his daughter doesn't want to include me nor acknowledge me and he says forcing her to include me will make her cut him off.  So he goes once a month during the week to babysit his grandchild and eat dinner with them.  They live 3 hours away so he leaves early AM and gets back late at night and uses 12 days of his vacation to do so because she doesn't have time for him on weekends typically.

He calls me almost the entire drive there and home.  Honestly it kindof drives me nuts because I am trying to distract myself from feeling left out, take care of my own kids, and get stuff done.  It seems like every time he goes we end up fighting afterwards while he is on his way home.  He seems on edge and so am I.

Recently he went to spend two days with them and travel somewhere.  I didn't say a word.  I didn't call or text him or bother him except when he contacted me.

A few days later he mentioned how perfect everything was and I said I don't think things are perfect, that I feel excluded from part of your life and wanted to discuss options.  It ended up in a huge fight.  We don't see eye to eye on the issue.  He thinks he is working on his relationship with her so she will eventually include me.  My point is after 7 years of this nothing is changing and now it's a point of managing my feelings of being excluded and left out of part of his life when he is included and invited in every aspect of limy life.

i asked him for this as something to try as a solution:  that when he goes to visit his daughter and granddaughter, just go.  Don't call me on his way there and back, don't send me pictures of where they are at and what they are doing, just go and come home and we don't need to discuss it at all then.

He thinks it is hurtful I don't ask how his trip went, I think it is hurtful sharing details of something I am not allowed to go to.

Am I being unreasonable saying if I am not invited I don't want to be the support for the boring drive there and back nor be shared the details of where I wasn't wanted?

Any other solutions any of you have found?

 

 

Elea's picture

You don't need to carry the emotional burden for him or be his meat shield. I think it is perfectly reasonable for you to refrain from playing therapist for your husband to dump the weight of his visits on. He can get an actual therapist to help him work it out.

My SD's also exclude me. I have gotten to the point where I realize that they are actually doing me a huge favor. They are not the type of people I want to have a connection with.

It's too bad that you've entangled yourself so much because now it will be more obvious that you are withdrawing. When I disengaged I didn't make a big thing about it. I just quietly stopped bringing them up, stopped asking questions about my step-diablas and stopped engaging when DH talks about them. When DH brings them up with friends or family I casually walk away. I don't want to be involved. I know I don't like them (for very good reasons) and I have accepted that fact without judgement of myself. They are horrible but if other people find them interesting then they are free to have a relationship with them.

 

Elea's picture

Oh, and as far as "SD is changing" and "we had such a great time together." Let it go!

My DH will cling to every crumb as if he has been given an iced cake. Most of the time they are miserable to be around. He knows that, I. know that. 

He has a fantasy that everything will turn out happily ever after. That's his fantasy, not mine. I see the reality. I let him live with his feelings about it. He has a right to his own dreams. There is no need to take it on as your own nor to contront him on it. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

If he does have a nice time with them then I am geniunely happy for him. I don't want to be a part of it but I'm glad he has moments with his daughters that aren't horrible.

I came back to say that using his vacation days is bonkers. He should be seeing them on the weekends. He is a grown man though so if he wants to waste his vacation days that's up to him. If I were you I would take a 2 week trip to a dream destination without him.

Daisygirl99's picture

Yes He can enjoy them and have a nice time with them and we don't need to hear from each other for the day until he comes home late and I don't need to talk about them.

He compares it to me sharing about my kids, who he lives with and functions as a father to, when he misses something with them..... he said it's no different than me sharing things about them with him and how he asks about them...

No sir, it's not the same.  When he doesn't attend things, it was by his own choice, not because he was purposely excluded or not invited.  Not the same thing at all!  He lives with them and gets hugs and kisses and we love yous from them.  If he misses something it was his own choice or because he has other priorities, not because he wasn't wanted there and wasn't allowed.  We "allow" him at everything.

plus if he doesn't want me to share I won't....

Elea's picture

I can relate to a lot of what you have experienced. You should not have to carry his baggage or be guilted into enmeshment.

My Dh has never had the nerve to say me talking about my kids it's the same as him talking about his and in general he doesn't guilt or pressure me to talk about the SD's. 

He does bring them up more often than I would like and he shows me photos that I don't really care about. He has mentioned that I seem disinterested when he talks about them. He's not dense. He knows exactly why. 

However, one thing I did have to explain is that I'm not pulling back from the SD's to be mean or for revenge but rather because I have to protect my own emotional and mental well-being. Their excluding, mean, rude behavior and actions towards me are hurtful and upsetting. I have to guard my own heart because it is painful to be treated that way. I have an autoimmune disorder and I have to reduce my stress levels, doctor's orders.

When he talks about the SD's I give short responses. I change the subject, often to my bio children or my own interests or I find something to do. I don't find the topic of SD's to be enjoyable or interesting, in fact, hearing about most of the stuff they do is annoying and raises my stress hormones. I know DH doesn't want to hear negative things about how and why SD's are being stupid, irresponsible, selfish, etc so it's best I don't say anything at all. It's his job to carry the weight/burden of SD's stupidity, bad personality etc., not mine.

We have argued when he has said that my bio-kids are hard for him too. It's absolutely not the same. His daughter's are rude, mean, full of drama and manipulative. Unlike the steps, my bio kids have never actively tried to get rid of DH and destroy our marriage. My kids have varying degrees of a relationship with DH, some very close to him like he's a 2nd Dad, and some not really close but they are all polite, kind, and don't cause any drama.  Not the same at all. I think these men just say this as a way to deflect and live in a fantasy world of their kids not being that bad. They're HORRID. I know this but it's not my mission to rub his nose in it.

Daisygirl99's picture

She only has time for him during the week and he works Monday through Friday so if he wants to see his granddaughter that's when he goes.  He uses one day a month on average.

Then he is in a bad mood when he goes back to work and is overwhelmed.  Thus the fighting.  It's not my fault he is taking off all the time, he isn't taking off for my kids.

That being said I just don't even care about it anymore.  He still does a few long weekend vacations with us.

SD weekends are for her mom and her friends, not dad.

frustrated78's picture

That alone should tell him just how important he is to them.  Not wanting him around on weekends because she has better things to do and other people to be with.  Sounds like my SD in that.

Toaster's picture

You wrote:

She only has time for him during the week and he works Monday through Friday so if he wants to see his granddaughter that's when he goes.  He uses one day a month on average.

Then he is in a bad mood when he goes back to work and is overwhelmed.  Thus the fighting.  It's not my fault he is taking off all the time, he isn't taking off for my kids.

Comment:

Ever think that maybe, just maybe, the whole “weekday-only visits” thing isn’t just about convenience—but actually the SD’s clever little way of burning through all of Daddy-O’s vacation days? That way, when it’s time for an actual vacation, he’s got nothing left… especially not for the evil, undeserving stepmother.

Mission accomplished.

He’s sulking because he’s not actually part of a loving family reunion—he’s just enrolled in the Rent-a-Daughter™ and Grandbaby-on-Loan Program.

Premium package.

But here’s the catch: if he doesn’t act the way Princess Rent-a-Daughter expects (think: trained seal) and jump when she snaps, poof—access revoked. (See wicked cult-leader BM in the background, grinning.)

No (pay as you go) grandbaby snuggles, no (fake) daughterly affection, just radio silence… until the next emotional blackmail invoice arrives.

ESMOD's picture

IMHO.. I am ok with him making the trip... AS LONG as it is not preventing you from doing things as a couple.  Are you unable to take vacations because he has burned all his vacation on his monthly visits?  Then THAT is the hill to die on part.  

"I don't mind if you go see your daughter and granddaughter, but when you end up using all your vacation time, that impacts both of us... You need to figure out how to use less vacation days visiting.. no more than 5 a year seems resonable"  

Of course, that will likely mean trips on weekends.. so is his absence more or less obvious to you or impactful to you on a weekday vs a weekend?  You can decide which is preferrable... and work with him to make things fit for you as a couple better.

Second.. I will say that when you didn't call.. didn't talk through the free time on the trip.. that seemed to actually give you and him less stress.  I don't think it's necessarily reasonable to tell him he can't go..(barring financial strain issues.. time off issues) but you can save yourself the blow by blow.

I am not sure you will ever get the utopia result that you might want.. which I guess would be one of two things.. she welcomed you and accepted you.. or he ceased vists to her.

and...I'm actually one of those people that feel as adults..we can choose who we spend time with.. and honestly given the history...the less present this woman is in your life.. the better off you are.

Could he insist she include you? sure.. he can't make her like you.. and in the end.. why do we want to waste our time on people that couldn't care less for us?

So, demanding he not see his daughter unless you are included? I don't know if that's a "nuclear option" you would want to ask for.  If he does not see his daughter.. the resentment and blame you would likely get from him and others would probably cause more heartache than the current exclusion 1/30th of the month.

So, my advice would be to do what you did last time.. disengage from the situation.. and if he mentions it went well.. "that's nice dear".. and you plan things on that day for you and your other kids.. it's not like you have nothing else in your life right?

I mean.. do you do things without your husband ever.. with your kids.. with other relatives?  perhaps not for the same underlying reason.... but few couples spend 100% of their non-work hours side by side.  

Again, if this is causing financial strain.. causing limits on taking vacations.. by all means approach those issues.. but just seeing his adult daughter without you.. once a month.. is not particularly excessive imho.

Daisygirl99's picture

I have accepted him going, I am ok that he chooses to use half his vacation on her.

i just don't want the communication on those days.  I feel like I have to be the good wife while he calls me to entertain himself the 3 hours there and back and I want to make myself feel good, not be reminded I was not wanted.  I also don't want the pictures of what they are doing without me nor pictures of his dinner that I don't get to share with them.  It's just all a reminder that I am not included.

If they don't want me there fine.  Then let me make the day I want for myself, he can have his exhausting day driving 3 hours each way without me at their choice, and I will see him the next day to talk about our life together but not them.

thats all I am asking and he sees it as unreasonable and why do I not want to share in his joy...

ESMOD's picture

I must have misread this.. I thought he was happy the time that you didn't talk or call him. or did he call you on his long drive that time?  Maybe you meant when he said it was perfect.. he was "reminiscing" about his trip with her and the grandkid?  not that the lack of stress with you was what was good.

But.. in any case.

When he calls.. don't answer.. a quick text.. "sorry, in the middle of a project.. have fun drive safe".  You don't have to call him.. and can limit the calls and time you take.. no one is making your answer the phone.  I'm busy doing X with my kids.    

He may like that he can while away the hours on the phone.. but he can find someone who doesn't have something better to do right?

If he brings up something on the trip later.. or sends pics.. you can be non-committal and have the rote answers ready.

"oh, that's nice dear".  "gotcha" " great".. then "oh.. did you mail the card to granny.. pick up the dry cleaning.. where did you want to go to dinner tonight.. are we seeing fred and mary this weekend?..  or "that's nice.. oh.. little Timmy is doing so well in ART this year.. here look at what he drew".  just refocus to something you do have interest in.

If he asks why you don't want to talk about his daughter and granddaughter.. "well it's not that interesting for me to talk about people I don't really have any involvement with.  They are your relatives.. but I really don't have much interest in keeping up with people that I hardly ever see.. nothing against her.. she just isn't a part of my life.. so not really someone I care to spend a lot of time discussing."

but disengage.. grey rock.. don't let him suck you in.

 

Toaster's picture

That’s the whole point!
He’s now a proud subscriber to the Rent-a-Daughter™ & Grandbaby-on-Loan Program — Premium Package activated.

Included in your deluxe plan:
✔️ Guaranteed arguments between Daddy-O and the evil Stepmother
✔️ Carefully timed visits to guarantee Daddy-O and evil Stepmother can't have a vacation, together.
✔️ Unlimited-time offer for causing the evil Stepmother to feel shunned and ostracized.
✔️ Built-in wedge to destabilize even the most resilient marriage

BONUS:
Skids get to claim Daddy-O's denial of their unreasonable requests might trigger flashbacks to their unresolved childhood trauma!

Terms and Conditions Apply:
Emotional availability subject to daughter’s mood. Grandbaby access contingent on full compliance and enthusiastic submission to Rent-a-Daughter’s terms. Evil Stepmothers need not apply. Refunds not available. Side effects may include Stepmother's chronic resentment, marital strain, and spontaneous visions of clarity.

hereiam's picture

I don't think you are being unreasonable, at all. Why would you want to hear about thngs that you are purposely excluded from? Or hear about the person who is excluding you?

If he needs someone to talk to while he's on the road, he can call his daughter.

He is giving her his blessing to exclude you and that is hurtful. Also, she is completely disrespecting him, and his time, but I guess he's okay with that. Kind of pathetic, really.

If you are to be excluded from this part of  his life, you should be completely excluded and not have to hear about it or be any part of it. He wants it both ways, whatever is convenient for him.

Trudie's picture

I don't think you are being unreasonable, at all. Why would you want to hear about thngs that you are purposely excluded from? Or hear about the person who is excluding you?

This...exactly!!!

He is giving her his blessing to exclude you and that is hurtful. Also, she is completely disrespecting him, and his time, but I guess he's okay with that. Kind of pathetic, really.

Especially --> He is giving her his blessing to exclude you and that is hurtful.

He wants it both ways, whatever is convenient for him. Nope. Nope. Nope!!!

Dogmom1321's picture

Unless he is running out of vacation days if you go on a trip together, then I wouldn't care. Even if I were invited by SD, I would not go. Why would I want to babysit and do a favor for SD?

It IS unreasonable for your DH to expect you to talk on the phone for hours for a trip HE is choosing to take time & time again. He can listen to a podcast. Also, don't respond to any texts/pictures he is sending of his trip. If it meant that much to see, then SD would be sending the pics. Change the subject when DH brings up the trip. "What time will you be back? Want to go out to eat when you return?" etc. etc. Hopefully he will get the hint. 

Daisygirl99's picture

Yes but he says HE is hurt that I don't want to talk to him and ask him about them.....

I told him I would make the trip with him and be there for him with him but I don't want to be held on the phone all day nor hear details about it because it's a reminder that I was not wanted.

 

and yes, exactly that!  Call your daughter for 3 hours each way, not me!  It makes me feel used and interrupts my time with my kids or whatever I want to do for myself.  Not my fault he chooses the trek alone!

Dogmom1321's picture

HE needs to realize that he is not the only one who has been hurt in the process & needs to man up. Does he not think SD has caused YOU emotional damage? Maybe he needs to direct his feelings towards SD. He wouldn't be in this predicament if it weren't for her. Next time he says he is "hurt", I would tell him it is not fair to YOU he is blame shifting. That's exactly what he is doing. 

Trudie's picture

Agreed. All of it. 100%

Winterglow's picture

Ok, first off, he's only driving for THREE hours. He's a big boy and doesn't need you to hold his hand. 

Secondly, your best defence is telling him that being on the phone causes distracted driving and that's when accidents happen. If he protests, point out that a Canadian survey noted that the risk of accidents is the same whether you have the phone in your hands or on speaker. It's a question of attention. Even if he doesn't agree, you can still refuse because "you could never forgive yourself if ..."

advice.only2's picture

"I hope you have a good trip." You are acknowledging his trip yet not inviting any more conversation about it.  If he presses just tell him, you have discussed your feelings on this ad nauseum and won't be explaining anymore.  He is entitled to see his daughter and granddaughter and you are entitled to your peace of not having to discuss it. 

Harry's picture

He wants to see his DD and GD  in the middle of  the week.  I would make excuses not to talk with him for 6 hours of the trip.  '''Dishwasher is done haste to go''. ''Some on is texting....have to call them''.  If you want to go on a trip and need more vacation that on him to figure out 

Merry's picture

It would be rude for a friend to send you pictures and talk to you excitedly about an event she was invited to but you weren't. How is this different? Look at all the good food you missed! Look at the fine time we're having but you're not!

My DH and SD would spend hours playing the "remember when, Daddy" game. DH said that was her way of sharing her life stories with me so I could get to know her. Total nonsense. Excuses and justifications for exclusion. I stopped playing the game.

Even if your DH is trying to be nice by thinking he's including you this way, the fact that it hurts you should be enough for him to stop. Telling you how you should and shouldn't feel is not loving.  It would be SO much easier if you pretended everything was fine--easier for HIM. Sounds like he cares more about himself than about you.

 

Trudie's picture

Good points, Merry!

Food for thought.... If anyone other than family would do this, would we accept it? "But it's family." Yes, it's family and they should treat you better than anyone! What we permit we promote. I can't tell you how many times this scenario is played out in therapy sessions.

TKB11's picture

I would insist on counseling. Because that is not right. He should never exclude you like that. Can you imagine ever treating him that way? My guess is No, you wouldn't. I would definitely tell him counseling is a must. DH definitely has his priorities mixed up. 7 years is too long for that to be going on :/

hereiam's picture

he says HE is hurt that I don't want to talk to him and ask him about them.....

Oh, HE is hurt? Poor baby. He really needs to think about that statement.

He is being completly selfish but I guess that's where his daughter gets it.

I would just stop taking his calls when he takes these trips. Again, if you are to be excluded, then you need to be completely excluded and left to do your own thing, peacefully, while he is gone. The era of him having it both ways is over. If he wants to make these trips without you, then they need to be WITHOUT you. You will no longer be his backup entertainment while he's driving to see someone who disrespects you so. He is disrespecting you, also, and is expecting too much.

Why would you care to hear about somenone who wants nothing to do with you? Why would you inquire about them? Because she is important to him? Well, you are important to him, yet, his daughter wants nothing to do with you, so....

Stick to your guns. Tell him you are no longer willing to be his company on these trips, while not being able to actually accompany him. It's really not fair to you.

I understand that he wants to be in his daughter's life but he needs to think about the terms that she is demanding and the price of those terms. If he is willing to pay that price, fine, but you should not have to. You should not have hear about that part of his life (if you don't want to) and you should not have to use your time to talk to him on those drives. He needs to be a big boy and deal with his choices. Frankly, his choice to live by his daughter's unreasonable terms is not attractive.

A man living two different lives rarely works out and that is what his daughter is asking him to do. Both relationships will be less than ideal if he continues to try to force you to hear about of his life with his daughter (who wants nothing to do with you), when you don't want to hear about it.

I read your other post and there doesn't seem to be a valid reason for his daughter to act this way. He really needs to take that into consideration and put his foot down with her.

 

CajunMom's picture

You've gotten some great advice in the comments. I'll add my story/thoughts.

After 12 years of crap treatment (and a final straw), I disengaged completely from DHs kids. Went 6 years with zero contact. In counseling, we agreed with the therapist suggestion of DH seeing his kids away from our marital home. While not easy to start, it ended up being the greatest blessing to ME. In the early years, when DH left, we went zero contact until he returned home. We did not discuss his trip with his kids and really, never talked about them much at all any time. My stance was...we live split lives....DH had his life with me, our family, friends...and then DH had his life with his kids that I had (nor wanted) any part of. When he left, it was a nice break for me. Today, he calls me once a day and keeps me posted while traveling. Still....no kid discussions...mainly filling him in on my day.

Today, we've begun a bit of re-intergrating...on MY terms. Two of DHs kids have visited us with good outcomes. Still...there will be times when DH will travel to see them and I will not be going. They are welcome to step into my world...I refuse to step into theirs. We still don't discuss his kids much and I keep it "civil but superficial" when around any of DHs kids.

So, stand your ground...when he leaves to spend time with his daughter, he's leaving the world he shares with you and stepping into a world he lets his adult daughter control. He can be alone with his thoughts on those rides over and back. Be clear one more time and then just don't answer the phone. Also, strongly suggest counseling so he can wrap his stupid head around what YOU need to be accepting of this crap show. Counseling is what it took for my DH to finally "get it."

On those vacation days though....we had to deal with this...DH was using our entire budget to fly around the country to see his kids. I went two years without any traveling....something we planned to do in our retirement. I put my foot down and told him, the vacation budget is now split in half. You get yours...I get mine. You can spend all your money on visiting your toxic kids and I'll spend my share traveling with my friends. Guess what? He's now minimized all that travel to see his kids to now enjoying our retirement again with fun travels. 

Counseling and standing firm on your boundaries. Those are key. Best to you.

Tin Can Zen's picture

It looks like you have a lot of GREAT replies with wisdom and experience in them. 

I, too, am the not-grandma. There are a lot of us, hiding in plain sight. I walk along a river to meditate and come to terms with the issues of my stephell. I have walked so many hours, so many miles, so many buckets of frustrated tears. 

I decided that I was going to claw back my own joy, no matter the loneliness and pain. It was really hard to make choices for my own betterment, when he was going to see that baby, or hanging out with those hyena offspring of his. We, too, have a three hour buffer of a drive. 

I find that I am still as isolated and lonely, internally. But!! I have carefully built a structure of coping tools, activities to distract, and established a solid time to journal. I sometimes feel deep mourning at the growing distance between my husband and I. But I have turned a corner in that I don't feel left out, rather, I pity him for wasting his heart and time on those jerks when all the peace and belonging he wants could be found with me. 

As I tell my young adult sons, and my own aging self, and I offer to you: it doesnt get easier; you just get stronger. 

Sneakily: how about calling him during his drive, and making sure you are out and about and have your phone "die". Structure your environment so he just doesnt have that easy dial and dump on you. 

Disfunctionally: drink more wine on the DL? Rip a fine green bowl?

Therapeutically: get a walking group, tai chi in the park, go to the library for knitting hour.

Volume control: get engrossed in a really smutty/low brow/ idiotic book and zone out COMPLETELY in that world when he gets too aggressive with his verbal spewing. Works good for when the news in on repeat and a mister is spinning from media rage.

 

I hope you can pick up your "eyes" far enough to see that we not-grammas are here surrounding you, holding your heart in our care, and we are legion. You are not alone, friend. It's not right. And you have all the steel and brilliance to navigate this. 

CajunMom's picture

As I tell my young adult sons, and my own aging self, and I offer to you: it doesnt get easier; you just get stronger. 
 

Let me add - It's not that I don't care but rather I can't care. Because to care only hurts me in the end. 
 

And yeah, there are a lot of us not-grandmothers in this toxic StepHell.