You are here

Breakthrough with SD14

Bojangles's picture

I was fairly horrified at the prospect of being at home with SD14 for 10 days but things have taken a dramatic turn for the better. On the day of her arrival DH and I spent an hour preparing to discuss things with her. We made a number of decisions including doubling the duration of her grounding, removing the PC from her bedroom and putting it in a public place for shared use, restricting internet access to 2 hours and permanently disabling internet access from her laptop so it can only be used for schoolwork, and insisting that she provide the login details for her FB and email accounts.

Amazingly she handed over her logins without a word of protest. Then we had a long talk with her in a very measured way and tried a new strategy of using more lateral questions about what she has been doing and the people she has become involved with, instead of interrogating her about what she had been doing and why. Over the course of an hour or so she finally started to open up and the outcome has been remarkable. We have learned some rather worrying things which we are taking steps to deal with, there were tears and hugs and in the last 2 days her behaviour has completely changed. Last time she was here during her grounding she was quiet and withdrawn, spent a lot of time in her room and gave very little away as to whether she had actually taken on board what had been said to her about her behaviour. Having actually confided some of her thoughts and feelings she has suddenly dropped the slightly sullen 'you don't really know me' 'too cool for school' persona. This weekend she has been happy, helpful and sociable, spending most her her time downstairs with us instead of closeted in her bedroom. I can't remember the last time I have seen her so genuinely relaxed and happy. The girl who told me a week ago that she wasn't close to anyone and didn't like being close to people is suddenly finding that letting us in actually makes her feel a whole lot better.

Yesterday I found her in the kitchen talking to SD19 about staying longer with us, so I told her she could stay if that's what she wanted and her mum and dad would sort it out. Last night she told DH that doesn't want to go home she wants to stay with us, that she feels listened to here and it is less chaotic than home. We are pretty happy about this, although there is obvious irony in the fact that she only feels listened to because we have prised information out of her by hook or by crook!

And here's an interesting part, she does not like BM's Boyfriend. The reason for this is a sobering insight into the impact of excessive disengagement from SKids. She says he treats his BS4 completely differently from her and her siblings, he mostly ignores them or acts as though he couldn't care less about them. Now it is clear to DH and I that the boyfriend does care a great deal about them, he put money in to help buy SD19 a car, he was the one on the doorstep removing a drunken SD14 from the house she had already been banned from, he was kind and affectionate with SS12 and SD14 when they were younger. It seems highly likely to me that he has suffered the slings and arrows of step parenting in terms of lack of appreciation and has simply stopped wearing his heart on his sleeve and disengaged. But the impact of this is that SD14 now feels uncomfortable around him and uncomfortable at home. This backs up something I have suspected for a long time which is that whether they know it or not SKids NEED to feel cared for and loved by the step-parents in their lives, even if they are not able to love them back like a parent.

DH and I talked about this after our discussion with SD and he had a further conversation last night where he suggested to her that perhaps she was getting back what she was putting in in terms of her relationship with BM's boyfriend, and pointed out all the evidence that he does care about her. She is giving this some thought.

Meanwhile BM has phoned from her holiday to suggest that SD is flown out to rejoin the holiday, or that we send her to stay with BM's sister. This is typical of her crazy inconsistency. DH said no, things were going well and SD was happy. BM is going to have a fit when she gets back and finds out SD does not want to go home. Which will be deeply ironic given that she just finished blaming SD's behaviour on DH leaving her. DH is going to have to handle it very carefully because if BM starts weeping and passive aggressively blackmailing her into going home it is going to undo all the good work.

I am so proud of my DH, he has done some really exceptional fathering over the last few days, especially during the the challenging first discussion with SD, and I am quite proud of myself. Maybe SD will be alright after all.

Comments

Last-Wife's picture

Wow. So happy for your family. Hopefully things will continue on this path. Best wishes!

wriggsy's picture

I have a question and please ladies...no hidden reasons or agendas here...I really am confused in my situation.

I read this post and wonder why can't all skids have that moment of clarity that helps them see that we (Sparents) were only trying to do our level best. I know that BM's have a great deal to account for in this mess, but still I wonder.

I am so happy for you Bojangles, but do you or have you ever had what you thought as a "breakthough" with SD only to have it fall through and have life go right back to the way it was before?

DH and I are currently going through a pretty good time with SD, she is being happy/silly/charming/endearing. She talks to us...even to ME! It's going really well right now. But, the qualifier is the fact that BM has been working out of town for the last week and won't be home until next week. However, even in the days before BM left, SD didn't go over to her house...she stayed at DH's house. The second day of school, BM was there to pick up SS and SD. I park across the street in another parking lot (all three kids go to the same school, so I would still have to pick up my BD), so they had to walk past BM, down the road to the crossing guard and back up the road to my car. SS went to his mom's car, got in and they waited on SD. She just waved and walked past BM's car and came home with us. VERY strange!

I would love to say that things are changing for us, but this has happened before. When BM is dating or married, SD doesn't really like going over there, because BM doesn't give her enough attention. But, when BM is single, we can hardly get SD to come home!! We hardly saw her the whole second half of summer (after summer school was out), and now...she doesn't even ask to go to her moms! The scary thing is when things are going really well between SD and myself...that's usually when I start getting accused of various kinds of bad behavior!!!

I guess what I am asking ya'll, how do you deal with a skid that suddenly starts acting nice? Do you take it with a grain of salt, do you enjoy it to it's fullest, or do you hold them at arms length?

Bojangles's picture

That is a very interesting question wriggsy. The answer is no, we have never had a breakthrough like this with SD14 before, and this is a breakthrough for both DH and I because she has pretty much kept both parents and step-parents at arms length since her mum and dad separated. Even when she was a little girl she always kept her thoughts to herself. In the past there have been periods when she would seem a little more engaged in our household than usual, but nothing like the major shift in mood and engagement we have seen this week. I am certain that she is not 'acting nice', her behaviour genuinely reflects the fact that she feels happier and more secure. So I am not taking it with a pinch of salt, but at the same time her teen years are far from over so I am not expecting the 'high' she's experiencing from being honest with us to continue unabated. I am not holding her at arms length, on the contrary her discomfort with her ambiguous relationship with BM's boyfriend has just reinforced my belief that I need to be a stable, caring, affectionate figure in her life, even if being that way sometimes requires some effort and going through the motions on my part.

SD14 is my fourth step-daughter, with her older sisters we have never been in a situation where one of them asked to stay with us instead of the BM. My second step-daughter did play favourites at one point by refusing to see us for 10 months after our we announced our engagement, but that reflected her own problems coming to terms with her parents divorce and when she finally got over it, that episode was over as quickly as it had begun and was never repeated.

It's sounds like your SD is consciously or subconsciously punishing her BM for dividing her attention when there is a partner on the scene. If so, SD avoiding the BM is a sign of the strength of her love for her, rather than the other way round. This must be very discomfiting for you and the BM as it's not nice to be played off against each other. The BM must hate to see her daughter going to another woman instead of her, and as a step mother it can be hard not to experience a triumphant moment of 'ha!' when you get a glimpse of what it must be like to be the number1 female parent figure!

It could be that your SD is not aware that she is manipulating the situation in this way and is simply acting on her own unhappiness when her BM has a partner in the house, but either way if I were your DH I would be trying to discourage SD from playing favourites in such an obvious way, because he's going to be at the other end of that when the pendulem swings the other way. So I would be taking it with a pinch of salt. If it were not for the fact that my SD has some serious issues which I know would be exacerbated by a return to BM's house I would not be countenancing extending her stay here, because of all the friction that is inevitably going to ensue. I don't know if any of this is any help, but those are my thoughts.

wriggsy's picture

Thanks Bojangles. I appreciate the advice! My SD is really just that manipulating, so I guess I will see what happens when her BM comes back in town (currently working out of town, but I believe coming home this weekend).

Thanks again and I wish you continued success with SD!!!