You are here

Stepmothers Stand NO Chance

AVR1962's picture

Found this and wanted to share:

• "The kids are hostile and rejecting no matter what I do. I know it's not their fault. But it's as if I'm not supposed to have any feelings about it, let alone discuss them."
• "I can't do anything right--if I buy them a present, they think I'm buying their love and if I don't, I'm cold and unloving."
• "My husband doesn't have many rules--so I look super strict and mean if I ask them not to eat with their hands!"
• "Their mother says unkind things about me and calls every half hour while they're here. So it's hard to build a relationship with them."

These women were no whiners--most had been trying to get stepmothering right for years, and all began their stepmothering journeys committed to forging a great relationship with his kids, whatever it took.

But they're correct that there are external forces, most beyond a stepmother's control, that may undermine her good intentions and best efforts with his children. These factors include loyalty binds, a child's jealousy and resentment, the Ex Factor, permissiveparenting, cultural expectations about women and children, and a phenomenon called conflict by proxy.
In spite of such obstacles, there is a widely-held notion that "If she's kind, they'll warm right up to her." "Just remember," one "expert" advised in an online article, "You'll get back what you give. Keep loving them."

In this formula, the only good or successful stepmother is one who is embraced by her stepkids. Here's why that standard is so off the mark--and why kids of all ages really dislike their stepmothers.

Loyalty binds. Many stepkids--and adult stepkids--suspect that liking stepmom would be a betrayal of mom. So they keep her at arm's length--or worse. And there's nothing she can do about that. Only mom can release them from the torturous loyalty bind and pave the way to a healthy stepmom/stepchild relationship, by saying, "I wish you'd give Jenny a chance. I won't be upset." Too often, no such permission is given.

When there is a loyalty bind, nothing's worse than stepmom bending over backwards to win the kids over. Drs. Larry Ganong and Marilyn Coleman found that such stepchildren and adult stepchildren are especially rejecting of a stepmother they find warm and appealing, as she elicits tremendously conflicted feelings.
Possessiveness and jealousy. Children may become remarkably close to their parents post-divorce, and used to having mom and dad "all to myself." Adult children may develop an intense, peer-like relationship with a single parent, making adjustment to a stepparent tough. With a preadolescent or adolescent girl, possessiveness and jealousy will pose an even bigger problem, psychologist Mavis Hetherington found. In her Virginia Longitudinal Study of families who divorced and remarried, preteen and teen girls especially described the stepparent as an interloper in their world and an obstacle to intimacy with mom or dad. A stepmother may encounter particularly fierce resistance from a teen girl, both because she is close to her father, and because teen girls tend to model the feelings and attitudes of their mothers.

The Ex Factor. While there are exceptions, an ex-wife generally poses more challenges for the stepmom/stepchild relationship than an ex-husband, stepfamily experts Constance Ahrons, Anne C. Bernstein, and Mavis Hetherington found. Why? Mom's more likely to be the primary parent, and to have a strong agenda about what goes on in her ex's household. The stronger the ex's agenda, researchers found, the more involvement across households--and opportunities for conflict. And high conflict situations between two linked households lead to greater resentment of the stepparent, who feels more expendable and less loved by the child than a parent. In addition, Hetherington found that ex-wives feel more anger, and feel it for longer, than ex-husbands. Stepkids pick up on these feelings--and often act them out on mom's behalf. Translation: stepmom loses this draw due to gender.

Permissive parenting. Research consistently shows that children do best with authoritative parenting--high levels of warmth and high levels of control. But post-divorce, permissive parenting (high warmth, low control) frequently prevails. Why? Mom is likely to have primary custody, and if she's single, that can mean a lot of work and stress. She might let the little things--and then the not so little things--go. Dad likely fears that if he angers his ex or the kids, he won't see them as much, and feels guilty that the kids went through a divorce. And so an "Always ‘Yes' Dad" is born. Against the backdrop of permissive parenting, stepmom's normal expectations about manners, scheduling and respect may seem draconian, rigid, and "unfair." And kids with permissive parents understandably don't have much sense that it's wrong to be rude to an expendable-seeming and "overreaching" (in their view) stepparent. This ticks off stepmom, who then seems even less likable and fun to her stepchild.

BarkAtTheMoon's picture

Funny how this dynamic is still in place, even after BM has died and I have SD19 and SD13 full-time. Even while BM was alive, she wasn't a problem. SD19 was always the problem. One time when SD19 was 14 she disrespected DH verbally at our home one weekend. I called her a "Bitch" and shocked the hell out of everyone. I sent her to the basement, where DH joined her 10 minutes later and let her sob in his arms. :sick: Later on when the SDs returned home to BM's house, SD19then14 told BM that I had called her a bitch for mouthing off to DH. BM's reply was, "Well, you were probably acting like one!" I remember in that moment of my first argument with SD19 when she was 14, she yelled out "You sound just like BM!!!" She still hasn't grown up and she will be 20 this month.

SD19 is now very possessive and uppity and insecure. She thinks she can tell me how she doesn't need me and she does this, that and the other thing all by herself. I know that she is getting these "things" taken care of by DH, who couldn't remember shit without me. It's mainly time management and finances. I stay in the loop so I know what's going on. Funny how here BoyF dumped her because all they did was argue. That was in May. Funny how it got so bad for me that I locked her in the garage and called the cops on her. Little snot left moments before they got there! That was on June 16th.

I'm glad SD19 has it all figured out. Grow up already.

~ Moon

hatesteplife's picture

Losing someone's parent does not give them the right to abuse someone else. Especially when they've been doing it for years, even before they lost said parent. That's the problem with my skids....they were always given excuses for their shitty behavior. DH realized it too late.

AVR1962's picture

And if bio mom would have done this it would have been different but stepmom are "supposed" to treat their steps like they are angels (which they are not) and how dare we treat them as bio mom would, or better.....we are in the wrong regardless!!

mommy0104's picture

I've often wondered if this is part of the problem with my skids. Maybe they are under the impression that DH would have more money to spend on them (because that's how BM shows her love) if myself and my bios weren't in the picture.

Amber Miller's picture

Yes!!! This is true in my situation. SD30 told daddy that she can't believe that he is supporting "those strangers" (my 3 boys and I) when he should be helping her. "How could you pick those strangers over your own daughter!" :sick:
Yes, she said this in an email. She also demanded to know how much money I have paid on my car! She said I sit around all day smoking weed (not true, I do not smoke). She's mad because the Bank of Daddy was closed when he realized that she was lying to him about going to college. After spending $50,000 on her in 4 years to bail her out of trouble, DH realized he was enabling her bad behavior.
SD decided to have a baby and thought that would be her ticket to being supported by mommy and daddy. Didn't work and now she's mad. Of course it's all my fault that she lied, manipulated, had a baby on her own, has no job and no car and is living in section 8 housing. Oh, and she told daddy that she was forced to work as a stripper because he "didn't provide her enough financial support" when she was in her mid twenties. Now she's in her 30's and still thinks she should be on daddy's payroll.
Disgusting.

Amber Miller's picture

I know. It's terrible. She hasn't spoke to DH in over 2 years. She said she will never see him or talk to him again until he divorces me. Then she emails this nonsense a month ago.
She's nuts.

Amber Miller's picture

Dup

Kaliko's picture

My DSO earns more than I do, but he's still saving a ton of money by splitting expenses with me. He has far *more* to spend on them than he did when he was living by himself in a little studio apartment. I wish I could explain that to them. :/

dood's picture

In a word (or 2 words actually): Cluster Fuck. Step-shit is a train wreck, cluster fuck.

Disneyfan's picture

Many if the reality shows out there are showing stepfamilies. Of course that focus isn't the intent of those shows, but it's out there.

I find it interesting to see how those families interact. (T.I. AND Tiny, Rev. Run and his wife, Cynthia, her husband and her sexy ex Leon, Kandi and her husband).

I don't think many SMs in awful situations would risk going on TV. BMs could use material from the show to bury the dad's in court. Slick editing and a stressed out/feedup SM is risky.

sandye21's picture

Why does it have to be a reality show? How about a situation comedy, showing doormat SM finding herself and setting boundaries. Could include Disney Dad and narcissistic SD. SM could have a friend similar to SDM with a wacko Twit character. Also a friend like Stepaside with three relationally aggressive SDs and a conniving MIL. Easy writing. All they have to do is read our posts. They would never run out of material.

kathc's picture

They can't do it because Hollywood makes far too much money on all the Brady Bunch happy horseshit stepfamilies where everyone loves each other in the end. If they showed the truth nobody would go to the stupid movies or watch the stupid tv shows claiming that it's all sunshine and rainbows.

AVR1962's picture

StepAside, my inlaws are holy people too, at least they think they are! My daughter was being excluded from play when all the girls were small, we were visiting sis-in-law. My daughter came up to tell me that husband's nieces would not let her play with them. Sis-in-law tells me she will handle this. I really thought she was sincere but I decided a few seconds later to follow and see what was said. As soon as sis-in-law got downstairs with my daughter she turned to her and told her that she (my daughter) just needed to suck this up, if the girls didn't want to play with her then they didn't want to play with her. I could not believe my ears. I went upstairs with daughter, told husband what happened and I left the house with my daughters. We were visiting out of town and I knew I had to go back. Daughter had been wanting a rabbit but there was not much for pets stores where we lived at the time. So, we picked up a bunny while we were out. Then sis-in-law accused me of babying and favoring my daughter by buying the rabbit for her but this was something we had planned anyway. Just sick and messed up. Sis-in-law was never very accepting of me and my daughters from my first marriage, the bad thing is she made it know to the family as well as my husband and she wonders why we don't get along??? Oh but she is such an uprighteous woman!!! Puke!

AVR1962's picture

You are not alone and don't feel bad. I am a very well liked person, work with children for a living but a whole different story when dealing with steps.

GhostWhoCooksDinner's picture

"Keep loving them." Riiiiight....

The more I loved them, the more I did for them, the more I showed I cared, the tighter the loyalty bind with BM. The more the PAS was ramped up.

Even when I backed way, WAY off, I still existed ,and that all it takes to be hated by skids and the BMs.

It's all such crap. A colossal waste of time and energy. I wish I'd invested my time, emotions, and money elsewhere. Anywhere but on the skids.

AVR1962's picture

>"You'll get back what you give. Keep loving them."<
expert saying this can just come and bite me..... it's not true

A statement I thought in my head was true an would eventually happen but never did.

Amber Miller's picture

Exactly. Just like my SD30 demanding to know what I've paid on my car. She wants to know how many payments I've made and in what amounts. She mad because she thinks daddy should buy her a car. Uh, he already did that. She trashed it.

still learning's picture

All of the bullet points from the SM author are spot on, this though "You'll get back what you give. Keep loving them." is utter hogwash. I thought this when I first embarked upon stepmotherhood but now I know that's just not how it works. What works for me now is treating the adult skids like guests. I'm kind and hospitable to them while they are here, I dote on the ss26's kids, I am extra sweet to ss30's gf (especially after seeing how horrid he treats her). I am the most gracious host while they are here and if I'm home but when they are gone they are gone. I've stopped engaging DH in discussions about them, stopped reminding him about gifts and fun things he could do with the grands etc.

They are like acquaintances to me but with very strong boundaries.

ldvilen's picture

Re: 10 Stepmonster Myths We Need to Bust Now, here is another good link: http://www.writtenvoices.com/article_display.php?article_id=872
Particularly interesting, "Bottom line: when there is conflict between a stepmother and a stepchild, look to mom or dad to understand why." And, MYTH #9: Being a Stepmother Gets Easier Over the Years. Sounds like above may have come from the same author?