You are here

Fiance's daughter is possessive of him

MelAnn's picture

HI everyone - I joined this site a couple of months ago and have read questions/comments but have yet to post. I have found many of your questions/comments helpful to my situation and can also understand many of your concerns.

Sorry if this is long, however I feel the need to throw it all out there.
My ex and I have been separated 4 years and divorced for 3 years; My fiance has been divorced 2 years.

I have a 9 year old boy (for further understanding - he is on the autism spectrum - high functioning and was diagnosed with Disruptive Mood Disregulation disorder (this is a fairly new label as kids used to be misdiagnosed with childhood bi-polar). I mention all of this as I feel it's necessary to understand background when answering posts, etc. He can be one of the sweetest kids ever and then can be one of the most challenging kids ever - and it can change from hour to hour.

I have a 6 year old daughter. It seems her brother has been mad at her from her birth basically just for being born (both kids see a therapist to deal with their individual issues - and have for years (my son since he was 3 and my daughter once she was old enough to speak her thoughts and needed to vent her frustrations of a brother constantly nagging at her).

My fiance has a 6 year old daughter (just three weeks older than my daughter). She was raised as an only child however she has two sisters from her moms first marriage who are in their 20's. (I say only child as really her sisters were more of caregivers to her than siblings - she never had competition for attention from a sibling). She's very sweet and gets along with both of my kids and is understanding of my sons special needs.

My kids were introduced to my fiance a few months after we started dating - approximately 2 years ago. My son has been all for it from the beginning and my daughter had a few issues at first worrying that her "mommy time" would get taken away. My fiance, then boyfriend, from time to time would take my son for a couple of hours so my daughter and I could have special time and then took my daughter a couple of times so she could get to know him better.

A year into our relationship I was able to be around his daughter (in their divorce paperwork neither could introduce their daughter to a significant other for 12 months from the divorce). We took it slow - I'd go to their house for a couple of hours once or twice a week for dinner or to hang out. After a couple of months we started hanging out with my kids involved too - all 5 of us. We'd get together one weekend day or some weekday evenings. I wanted to take her for an hour or two for bonding time - just the two of us - but she was never into leaving her dad for any amount of time.

So, there's our history as I felt it was important to show it wasn't like we jumped right into blending the family - we made sure it was a slow transition for all of the kids.

6 weeks ago we all moved into one home.

Here are some examples of my concerns............ if my fiance compliments my daughter his daughter will have a meltdown "but daddy, why wouldn't you tell me I looked pretty, you only told her, don't I look pretty?" If I am sitting next to her dad she will immediately come over and either get in between us or sit on his lap and say, in a baby voice, "my dada". I pick her up on Tuesdays from her sitter and many days she'll say over and over in a baby voice, "Me want to see dada. When will me see dada?"
A few weekends ago we had music playing outside and both girls were dancing. His daughter came in crying hysterically b/c it was 'her turn' to dance and didn't want to dance at the same time.

It's not as if she has to ask for attention - he's over the top "Hi sweetie - how was your day?" (plays with her, talks to her, etc) He calls her every morning and evening when she is with her mom. Thursdays are his nights too and they have their night where they will go to dinner by themselves or go to the park, etc.

He's usually very complimentary and loving towards me however when she is around it's so much more low key - kisses on the cheek hello rather than on the lips and rather than 'honey/sweetie' I am called by my name. I don't know if he is different because of the way she reacts and doesn't want to upset her or if she is possessive like this because he's always given her the #1 spot and always will.

I don't want to sound harsh - this is new to all three of the kids and I want to be understanding and compassionate through this. I just am not sure how to handle this - is it just a transition thing? Is it something I need to wait out? How do I say to her dad that her near constant baby talk when addressing him is like nails on a chalkboard? In your experience - if you've had one similar - what's the best way to address this?

MelAnn's picture

Thank you so much for your response!!!! I actually looked up the mini wife info recently as I read that (maybe in one of your posts?) and realized some of it certainly did apply!!

MelAnn's picture

You are all so wonderful with your insight and I appreciate it very much!!! Every one of you have given me wonderful advice and things to think about - and ways to approach it.

MelAnn's picture

Oh - I cannot believe I failed to mention a comment she made a couple of weeks ago. The 5 of us were all out to dinner. Out of nowhere she said, "MelAnn.....I don't want you and dada to have another baby because I want to be the only kid my dad has"

I didn't know what to say.......... Thankfully DF said "That's not true, L & M (my kids) are my kids too."

ncgal1980's picture

Oh GOD yes. Two of my former stepsons (then ages 6 and 7) used to do that all the time. My ex couldn't hear it for some reason. I guess he's heard it all their lives and is just used to it, but it drove me INSANE!

MsMad's picture

Hi,

I am with my partner and his daughter. I have been here since SD was 4 and she is now 12. I am not sure how I have done it at times, it has been a roller coaster and most days are a mixifmoids and emotions.

Her zBm is not around and SD IS VERY VERY CLOSE & clingy to dad. I can understand that she is insecure (maybe yours is too). Her mum and dad split and she doesn't want her relation with her dad to break. I have spoken with my partner and explained my concerns but that I understand.

I do tread on eggshells with kisses, sitting next to him, holding hands - but he has been able to say to SD that she should come on his other side and he can be shared. She also calls him daddy, and is like butter wouldn't melt with him. I have told him to toughen up... He has in bits, but the daddy thing I am living with as I know other split families where children call parents mummy and daddy.

Hope some of what I say is reassuring. X

Simpleton21's picture

I am new to this site. I stumbled across it when I googled how to deal with a jealous SD. It is nice to know that I am not alone! My fiancé and I have been together for a little over 3 years. I have a son from a previous relationship and he has a daughter. They are both 9 and together we have a 2 year old. I always hoped that dealing with his daughter would become easier but she does the exact same things you described and then some. The baby talk is super annoying and even when she says "daddy" it drives me crazy (maybe the tone she uses). I don't know. I try very hard to treat her as my own child and in all honesty she probably gets treated better than my children and I am so drained from it. I let them have their one on one time that they get every week but I never get one on one time with my children anymore.

I wish I had some advice for you. I just commented to let you know you that you aren't the only one struggling in this scenario!

I'm going to have to look up this mini wife syndrome or whatever!

My SD actually asked this past weekend, "I know I've asked this before but if you guys get divorced will we still get to see Sawyer?" This statement really got to me...first of all she asks stuff like this all the time (Sawyer is our son together)....and second of all I feel like it was completely inappropriate of her. I think she is old enough to realize what she is saying/doing. I am also irritated that her dad acted like it was no big deal that she said this and replied, "of course we would still get time with him!" UMMMMMM!!! I know it is mainly him not handling the situation with her correctly. We fight about this a lot because he treats her so different. I am at my wit's end with this one though Sad

MelAnn's picture

We just had a fight about our situation too... We had been on vacation since Thursday and I could not wait to get home. My kids are not angels, they have their own issues as well but I just get so friggin annoyed....... We all had a good time but now my kids are doing the baby talk thing. My daughter, same age as my fiance's daughter, said (to my fiance when he asked why she's doing it), "I'm doing it because "SD" does it." So, he's now on board with trying to get it stopped......... I also, when the kids were not around, stated that I get so frustrated, not simply with the behaviors, but at myself for letting it get to me as I feel I should be more patient and compassionate but that it feels many times that he and his daughter are the partnership and I'm the odd one out. (I had heard at some point over the weekend she asked her dad for some snack and his response was "well, no, because if you get (whatever the treat was) I'll have to give one to L&M (my kids)" I got so upset - what the heck? What kind of response is that and what message is that giving her???????
During our talk I shared all of this as well as other examples and, of course, he said it sounds like I resent her and I'm judging his parenting. I went further explaining that it's simply I feel I don't have a say - like they have their thing and me and the kids are separate.......we should, if we're going to be one, act like a family.....

As terrible as this sounds I'm actually thankful for the next week - my fiance is out of town for the week and it's just me and the kids until Friday when they go with their dad and then I have time to myself. I'm worked up, probably too emotional, and need my time to sort it out in my own mind. Possibly I'm overreacting but I feel my feelings are true, ya know?

BonusMom15's picture

I just want to say I can relate. My sd8 is super-clingy toward her daddy. I'm not sure how to respond when she comes over and sits in between us or on his lap when we're trying to sit next to each other, or when we're at a restaurant, and she insists on only sitting next to daddy, with me and sd6 across the table. This will be one of a few things I'll bring up with our new therapist (who specializes in step-family dynamics) this evening.

MsMad's picture

Hi,

I can totally relate to your circumstances of super-clingy; how are things going now? Has the therapist helped? It'd be great to hear how things are going for you!

Rags's picture

Daddy needs to grow some balls and not modify his behaviors for a 6yo. Rather than tolerate her whiney crap he needs to address it... each and every time.

If he doesn't this 6yo has an overwhelmingly likely chance of becoming an intollerable teen.

Better for DH to jump on this hard than tolerate it and allow it to get out of control.

IMHO of course.

Good luck.

MelAnn's picture

Thanks everyone - things have gotten a little better. Fiance has started addressing the baby talk and the whining each time she does it. "I'm not answering to 'me want....' You speak like a 6 year old if you want something" She doesn't like that and then whines but I don't expect a change overnight, ya know.

Last week was parents night at my daughters school so all three kids were with fiance for the hour I was gone. They were all happily playing outside on bikes/scooters when I left. When I got home all were inside, SD looked like she'd been crying and fiance looked exhausted...... My daughter is still getting comfortable on a 2 wheel bike and she apparently fell and scratched her foot up pretty badly.........so fiance was helping her calm and clean off her foot, etc. and he said all of a sudden his daughter is screaming as if she just broke her arm. Ran out back to see what was going on......"You are paying attention to her and me and L (my son, 9) are playing and you're not paying attention to us!" Not just whining - full on screaming and sobbing. (Thankfully I did not witness it but that sort of thing is not uncommon) Funny thing - at school that day his daughter received an award for being kind and considerate of others. LOL!!!

Fiance and I are going to start pre-marital counseling coupled with step-family therapy in a couple of weeks. Again, I don't expect overnight changes, but hopefully will help bring us all a little more peace and understanding.

Rags's picture

That was the perfect opportunity for DH to give the screaming and crying brat something to scream and cry about.

Rogue's picture

Im dealing with the same crap, but my SD is 18!!!!! Trust me it doesnt get better, just worse! Im about to walk out on my marriage because of this Mini Wife syndrome! Sad