You are here

Homework/ Black history month/ what would you do?

BethAnne's picture

Every week my sd9 gets set reading comprehension type homework which is set from a text usually relating to something topical for the time of year. This weeks text is about black history month. Twice in the text they refer to Africans (note, NOT African-American) where they presumably mean black people in general.

I find this inaccurate language to use and offensive to assume that all black people are African and all Africans are black. I know there are no perfect terms to use when we decide to delineate ourselves (or others) by race, but I do feel that using African in this context is wrong.

I have discussed this with my husband. He seems resigned that it is the school district who are probably at fault and has suggested that if I want to I could write a letter to the principle. As a step mom, a white woman and someone who is not American (and sadly was not taught much about black history) I am struggling to feel that this is my place to point this out, although it disgusts me that this is being taught to a multiracial, multinational class of children in 2017.

So my question to you all is, what would you do?

ETA: I posted a copy of the text in a message below if you want to read it.

Comments

BethAnne's picture

Just to add, sd lives with us full time during the school year. BM is a few states away and uninterested in SD's schooling. My husband does interact with the school but I do a lot too.

libbie's picture

I don't know. My girlfriend says she is light chocolate and not black. She wants to be addressed as African American and not as black. My sisters husband says he is black and not from Africa. He gets offended at African American. I'm just a white girl who tries not to offend others. Smile

Disneyfan's picture

If the people they are referring to are descendants of the African diaspora, then the the term is correct.

Black history is NOT just about the history of African Americans. If it is being taught correctly, it will never fit into just one month. It will include the contributions of blacks throughout history and around the world. And it will not start with slavery or Civil Rights.

libbie's picture

Did you know the man who invented chips is a black man? George Crum. I want to kiss and throat punch him all at the same time!

Acratopotes's picture

it's a war blog then...

Africans are born in Africa, regardless your skin color
Americans are born in America.... regardless your skin color

There's no such country as Africa-America, so where does these people come from then? I know about the slavery that happened and yes those people where Africans, but sorry first generation born on American soil is American...

BethAnne's picture

The worksheet on thanksgiving (and Columbus Day too) was pretty one sided. We tried to talk to sd about it at the time in the hope that she learns a broader view of history. I know they can only teach so much and they want to make American kids proud to be American, but erasing who hosts of people and events is not s great way to do it.

ESMOD's picture

My 2 cents is that you very rarely get any traction pointing out errors etc... in school materials.

There were multiple times I saw errors in my SD's homework assignments and and materials. For example, a word would be defined incorrectly. it would be similar, but not exactly right.

I tried to teach the girls the correct meaning but for the test/homework, you have to spit back at the teacher what the teacher wants to to say.

BethAnne's picture

It is a worksheet, I do not know where it is from. Here is what is written in the worksheet:

Black History Month

Black History Month is a month to honor accomplishments. It is presently recognized in the United States and Canada during the month of February. It is also known as African American Month in the United States. Other countries, like the United Kingdom, recognize it during different months.

Black History Month first started in the early 1900's. It was originally a week long. It was created by many African college students that wanted to honor their heritage. They contacted many schools, state leaders, and city officials to support the week. At first it started out slow, but states soon started accepting the week. Then in 1976, President Gerald Ford and the United States government declared February as Black History Month. The historical week was now observed by the rest of the county for the whole month of February.

During Black History Month, many public schools will get involved. Teachers mainly teach about the accomplishments of Africans. Some schools have essay and writing contests. Students will write reports about inventions, leaders, athletes, and changes. Hallways and classrooms can have decorations honoring the month. Events that happened in history, stories, plays and other accomplishments become part of what is taught in schools. There are even commercials, that will honor February as Black History Month.

Stepped in what momma's picture

Google "white African Americans" very interesting read and prospectives.

BethAnne's picture

All of the worksheets she gets are appallingly written, along with the corresponding questions she is supposed to answer. I just ignore it usually but I was struck by this one as being offensive.

Disneyfan's picture

I read this 4 times and each time I asked myself how can an educator teach about the foundations of black history week/month and never mention Carter G. Woodson? :?

I find it interesting that tthe white man who declared February black history month is mentioned, but not the black man who is called the father of black history. Why not mention both men?

The use of word African in this context is puzzling.

And the write is appalling.

BethAnne's picture

I agree it is not a great way to teach kids.

Disney, as a teacher do you get to select the individual worksheets that you teach in class or is it decided by the school or school district?

T2B87's picture

That can be school dependant. I've worked in schools where I was only permitted to pull from certain sources. Another one would choose assignments and readings for special events and require us to use those. I had to use a pre-approved lesson from the district for MLK day, President's day, etc.

T2B87's picture

One reason I'm not anymore. Not having any control on the curriculum or methods used in my classroom was a killer for me.

moeilijk's picture

I find this so difficult to address myself. Words and ideas are powerful things, so I would not let this stuff stand. But that's also why I would have to reflect carefully on what I want to teach my kid.

I think there would be quite a list.

* Being a student means learning to follow instructions. And some teachers will tell you to walk backwards and stand on your head and that 2+2=5, and it's your job as a student to say, "Yes, ma'am, or Yes, sir," and walk backwards and stand on your head and write down 2+2=5. And come home to talk about how silly and wrong it all is.

* It's ok to speak to the teacher about it as well. But teachers are just people, and some people won't admit when they've made a mistake. So if the teacher still insists that 2+2=5, now you know more about the teacher.

* I would ask my kid to do a 'real' essay about the topic. Specifically, assign three facts she can look into and write about. At age 9, it seems kids learn best following the 'Great Person' approach to history, so ask her to write about Carter G. Woodson, Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln, and why they were important people in American History.

The thing is, we can't protect our kids from thinking we don't agree with, we can't protect them from temptation, from evil.... except by teaching them to think critically and to independently investigate truth. So I'd teach them that I expect her to do just that.

Disneyfan's picture

I have to agree with ESMOD. But it gies deeper than just admitting to a mistake

Most schools will teach a lie because it's easy.

For example most teachers will teach that Rosa Parks was a tired seamstress who refused tomgive up her seat on the bus. That's a feel good lie that doesn't meake white kids, parents and teacher uncomfortable. It's a lie that doesn't empower black children to challenge the status quo.

Most students aren't taught that Parks was a rape investigator for NAACR. They don't know that she went to Montgomery to investigate the gang rape of a black woman by a group of white men. Kids aren't taught that Parks, King, Ella Baker, Myles Horton....all attended Highlander Folk School-a schoolnfounded for POOR WHITE and blacks to teach social justice and leadership training.

For most part, schools ar enornin the business of empowering the masses. There is a difference between EDUCATION and KNOWLEDGE. One produces worker bees who simply do what is expected. The other produces critical thinkers who will question and challenge the status quo.

tonieye11's picture

It is not just what we are not taught. My mindful*k moments came from incorrect things I was taught based on bias. For example the Black Panther Movement was a terrorist organization or communist in intent.

BethAnne's picture

Thanks for this. I am ignorant of many historical facts having studied history for only a very brief period during my education and then only from a highly biased point of view. I aim to educate myself with better knowledge, I think I shall find some biographies to add to my reading list.

moeilijk's picture

That there are so many people who have been 'educated' with incomplete/incorrect or even total DISinformation who have no idea that they should be seeking more information.

For myself, thank you for mentioning this here. I just spent some time on Wiki learning some basics I already thought I knew.

tonieye11's picture

Although the text is rather poorly written the overall use of African in this context is fine. Black History Month, while typically focusing on African Americans/Blacks in America, should and could include the accomplishments of Black Africans independent of location. This would include those from Africa, America, Caribbean Islands, etc. spanning a great deal of time. By using African the authors are (seemingly) trying to be inclusive of all those of African decent independent of slave related ancestry.

BethAnne's picture

I had always thought if African to refer to someone from the continent of Africa (or perhaps children or maybe grand children of those from Africa). I can see from your response and Disney's response above though that some use it to describe anyone with black African ancestry. I was under the impression that when used about someone who is not themselves from Africa (but is black) it can be perceived as negating that persons nationality and right to be a part of the country they live in. Thank you for informing me of another point of view.

tonieye11's picture

The argument tends to come from whether one is talking about ethnicity or one is taking about race. Is discussing ethnicity, I am Black and American. If we are talking about race, I am of Black African decent. I understand those who hate the phrase African American I can't stand it either, I am singularly American. But when discussing the history of my people negating the African and Caribbean component and focusing whole on slavery and Civil Rights is really narrowing the focus of the black/African (all inclusive) contribution to society.

BethAnne's picture

I just did a refresher in the difference between race and ethnicity. Thank you. That is a useful difference to bare in mind. I am still leaning towards the feeling that in this context African is, in the very least, a confusing term to use in the homework. I am not sure many children will understand the difference between ethnicity and race.

notarelative's picture

SD is nine. Nine is third or fourth grade. There is only going to be a basic overview at this age. There is going to be very little of the complexity of the issues in these grades.

This is one worksheet. If you see a pattern of wrong information that you would like corrected, go in to see the teacher and explain your reasoning.